Kindling Board Engagement in Fundraising

Perhaps you’ve shared over coffee: “part of your role as a board member would be fundraising,” and you’ve seen the prospective board member in front of you visibly flinch, their stomach presumably performing backflips. 😬

I’ve been there and it’s a rough moment to navigate. But it’s important to stay the course, because fundraising IS a vital part of board members' roles. The good news is I can share though – channeling Inigo Montoya from The Princess Bride – is this: 

“You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.”

Because true “fundraising” is not about “GETTING THE MONEY.” It’s not a grab, a gimme, or a hustle. It shouldn’t be anyway, because that’s gross! 

In my world, it's about building relationships based on shared values, and then inviting others to take action. 

This is when generosity flows! This is how your mission-driven work gets funded! 

And there are many ways board members can participate in fundraising, beyond making direct asks. 

A More Inviting Approach to Board Fundraising

For years, I've encouraged nonprofit leaders to offer their board members a menu of fundraising activities.

Rather than expecting everyone to fundraise in exactly the same way, we can invite board members to identify activities that feel accessible, meaningful, and aligned with their strengths.

And then a brilliant client of mine, Association for Environmental and Outdoor Education (AEOE), took this idea and made it a LITERAL dinner menu. Complete with appetizers, main courses, and desserts! 🍽️

I absolutely love it.

Imagine inviting your board members to choose from activities like these:

  • Appetizers: Share a story about your organization's impact on social media, invite a friend to an event, or help research prospective supporters.

  • Main courses: Introduce a potential funder, host a gathering to introduce friends to the mission, or participate in a donor meeting led by the ED. 

  • Desserts: Make a personal thank-you call, write a note of gratitude, or share an impact update with someone who has supported the organization.

Suddenly, fundraising becomes something board members can participate in with curiosity and enthusiasm rather than dread.

But here's the important part: The menu is just the beginning.

The Magic Is in the Conversation

I encourage nonprofit leaders to sit down with each board member and explore:

“What appeals to you? What feels accessible? What might stretch you in a meaningful way? How can I support you?”

“And yes, let's also talk about your own giving. What kind of financial commitment would feel meaningful to you this year?”

These conversations definitely take time. But they create a foundation of shared understanding, personal ownership, and genuine engagement that make a world of difference. 

We're not simply assigning fundraising tasks. We're inviting people into a relationship with the mission – and helping them discover how they want to contribute.

Values-Aligned Fundraising in Practice

I recently had the pleasure of joining Scott Shepherd on his Hopeful by Nature podcast to explore what values-aligned fundraising looks like, particularly for outdoor and environmental education nonprofits.

This conversation was especially close to my heart because I began my fundraising career in outdoor education, raising scholarship funds for YMCA camps and Outward Bound California. 

We explored everything from engaging board members in fundraising to navigating the vulnerability of donor outreach – and what happens when a donor gives less than we'd hoped.

One of the themes we kept returning to was that alignment doesn't mean the absence of discomfort.

Sometimes doing something deeply aligned with our values – e.g. making an inquiry or an ask – requires us to step outside our comfort zones. And that's something outdoor educators know a thing or two about!

Watch our conversation:

Scott also wrote a beautiful companion article, using the metaphor of a backpacking resupply to explore the choices we make, what we carry, and how our values guide us when things get difficult.

Read Scott's companion article

Ready to Build a Fundraising Program That Feels Like You?

The board fundraising engagement menu is just one of the practical tools I share through my Authentic Fundraising Accelerator.

Designed for nonprofit leaders who want to raise more money without sacrificing their values, the Accelerator combines practical training, personalized guidance, and ready-to-use resources to help you develop a fundraising plan that works for your organization.

Our next cohort is planned for spring 2027.

Explore the Authentic Fundraising Accelerator

Or, if you'd like to start with something a little more lightweight, join me for my free Deeply Authentic Donor Outreach workshop on January 15.

Learn more about the workshop

Because fundraising, at its best, is an act of love. And we don't have to become someone we're not to do it well.

Next
Next

Building a Fundraising Program From Scratch - A Conversation with Michael Thiele and Gia Baiocchi of Apis Arborea